Micha Frazer-Carroll’s ‘Mad World’ fills me with Mad Pride

July 15th was Mad Pride, and I celebrated by reflecting on the newly released, ‘Mad World’ by Micha Frazer-Carroll.

The book reads like a breath of fresh air, as it provides a much-needed approach to mental health – one which is firmly rooted in a necessary anti-capitalist and abolitionist politics.

Exploring and rejecting the harmful limitations of ‘awareness-raising’ campaigns and diagnoses, Frazer-Carroll asks us to reckon with what ‘sanity’ would even look like in a world which works ceaselessly to drive us mad.

Frazer-Carroll approaches her discussion of mental illness through an explicitly political lens. In light of the demands of historical and contemporary capitalism, Frazer-Carroll asks us to question how the borders of mental illness are drawn – who gets categorised as mad, and why.

As Frazer-Caroll identifies, ‘Madness/Mental Illness are not the stable, concrete, or God-given categories that we are often led to believe they are’.

Frazer-Carroll questions whether the treatment of ‘mad’ people through the asylums and torture methods adopted in the past are uniquely villainous, arguing that modern ‘treatment’ for mental illness, purporting to be based in science and ‘rationality’, can be equally unpleasant, and drawn from similar ideologies.

This links to her broader disability justice approach, drawing on the work of theorists such as Mike Oliver who have questioned how much of disabled oppression comes from our bodies/minds, and how much from a society which is designed to exclude bodies/minds like ours.

Frazer-Carroll also addresses the ways in which particularly marginalised groups are more likely to lead less bearable lives, to be categorised and labelled as ‘mad’, and that this madness is more likely to be responded to with violence and oppression.

Frazer-Carroll explicitly counters the narrative that ‘mental health does not discriminate’ in a vastly discriminatory world.

People of colour are traumatised by navigating a ceaselessly racist society, and face increased diagnoses of mental illness. Black people, especially, see their genuine mental distress responded to with violence.

Frazer-Carroll succinctly observes that ‘Black distress is interpreted through the psychiatric gaze as irrational, dangerous and primal – something to be attacked rather than understood’. This analysis feels particularly prescient following the killing of Jordan Neely, a Black man experiencing distress on a subway, and the subsequent justifications given for that killing.

Similarly, borders enact violence which produces madness and disability. Trans people are subjected to oppression that leads to increased suicidality, whilst transness itself is framed as a mental disorder.

As Frazer-Carroll concludes: ‘The world makes us Mad, and then goes on to define who is pathologised as mad, and how they are treated’. Ideas about madness are inseparable from the other systems of oppression which dominate our society.

Perhaps most importantly, Frazer-Carroll’s book offers a sharp critique of contemporary responses to madness and mental illness. Frazer-Carroll warns against the flattening nature of attempts to fully understand mental health through mental health ‘awareness’ campaigns, and the way these campaigns prioritise the least taboo experiences of mental illness.

Contemporary approaches also erase the violence and inaccuracy of diagnosis and treatment, and which groups are able to access care, or are subjected to involuntary medicalisation.

Phrases like ‘everyone has mental health’ can not interrogate what it really feels like to be suicidal, and mask the ways in which certain types of madness are excluded from these messages, instead facing the sharp end of sanism.

Within these frameworks, the responsibility for eradicating sanism is often placed on the very people who experience it, by encouraging them to ‘speak out’ and to ‘bust stigma’.

Frazer-Carroll rightly notes that whilst celebrities in some contexts may receive a positive reaction for being vulnerable about their mental health, a mother who does the same may see her children taken away.

Instead, we should understand the limited use of ‘awareness’, become more comfortable with what we cannot understand, and prioritise empathy over attempts to diagnose, categorise, and process madness into oversimplified ‘rational’ confines. She summarises:

‘Ultimately, we cannot ever definitively know mental health, and so many of the ways we currently try to know it are restricted, oppressive or depoliticising.’

Whilst its critiques are incisive, Frazer-Carroll’s project remains an ultimately hopeful one, which posits disability justice as a tool for our liberation.

Frazer-Carroll encourages those of us who are mad to embrace the radical politics which permeates the disability justice movement, from crip theory to the importance of interdependence.

She powerfully argues that although whether those of us who are mad choose to identify as disabled is ultimately a personal choice, we should recognise that disability forms more than just an identity, but is rather a way of understanding and approaching our mad world: ‘disability is possibility’.

Frazer-Carroll ties this to art as a mad liberation tool, focusing particularly on the power of the zine. Engaging in an abolitionist project, Frazer-Carroll also invites us to imagine other possibilities for our approach to madness, reflecting on, for example, the ‘Trieste’ model of mental health care, which centres anti-carcerality, as opposed to domination and control. 

These calls for a better world are what makes ‘Mad World’ a truly powerful book, as it uses its criticisms of madness in the present to invite us to build a better future, together.

Mad World by Micha Frazer-Carroll is available now at Pluto Press

Love our content? Want to help us pay disabled writers and continue to build this amazing platform? Find out how you can support us

all Columns Editor notes Essays

Editors Notes: It’s Hard to get out of “Work Mode” When it’s Your Life – but I’m Trying

I’m very lucky that I get to make a living out of something I’m passionate about. However, the fact that my job is so connected to such an important part of my life, is often a detriment to me.

I always wanted to be able to give my community a voice and be able to shout about the issues disabled people face on big platforms, but in doing so, I use a lot of emotional and mental energy. It’s almost impossible to stop focusing on the things that I do for work.

We’re always told to have a healthy work-life balance but this isn’t always the case when your work is about your community and directly about the issues you face. 

all Essays

‘She’: Epilepsy, Mental Health, and Self-Detachment

TW: This article includes discussion of mental health, seizures, medical ableism and discussion of to eating disorders.

I recently sat down to write a poem for a competition entry. It was only when I re-read my work I realised in several stanzas, I referred to myself as ‘she.’ To my surprise, I changed them all to ‘I’ – but then, the poem didn’t feel right. So, I changed them back.

I’ve previously convinced myself that I’m nothing more than a consciousness. It’s usually when I’m in bed and have a chance to think. The more I think, the more life starts to unravel at the edges. The idea that individual souls are connected to individual bodies feels ridiculous, absurd.

The sensation mounts, and then something snaps. Sometimes, it feels like my actual bodily form is changing, until I half-believe that someone completely physically different is lying in my bed. 

all Essays opinion

What Happens if You’re too Broken for the NHS?

By all accounts, a lot of the stigma that once existed around mental health has been eroded. Studies show that people’s knowledge of and attitude towards mental health issues has significantly improved in the past decade, with a Time to Change survey reporting that since 2007, 4.1 million people have improved attitudes towards mental health. So, these days, it is a lot easier to open up about your mental health.

But it’s not enough.

We’re sold this story of everything getting better if we only just speak up -– like the only thing holding us back from recovery is ourselves – but the reality is a lot more complicated than that. A lot of public discourse emphasises how so many people with mental health issues are ‘suffering in silence’ and that if they only reached out to get help, everything and everyone would be rosy. But that’s not the case.

all opinion

Simone Biles is Not a Wimp. She’s a Woman Prioritising Her Mental Health, and I Respect That

TW: this article mentions of sexual abuse, in particular the abuses carried out by Larry Nassar against gymnasts.  

Simone Biles deserves a gold medal in courage. 

When she stepped away from the Olympics all-around event and decided not to compete, that took a huge amount of guts. But it’s no surprise she’s become a pro at being brave in the face of overwhelming stress. She’s had to, given her past. As the last gymnast abused by Larry Nassar (the prior doctor for the United States women’s national gymnastics) team still performing, she has been forced to deal with her ongoing personal trauma in front of the media.

 When the word came that “medical issues” were the reasons for her withdrawal, most people assumed them to be physical—an injury to her body, perhaps. That it takes society a beat or two to realize that mental health concerns are equally important, and also a potential medical issue, says something about how far we still have to go when it comes to awareness and compassion. 

all Essays features Stories

Self Forgiveness After the Storm: how I Learned to Live a Better Life with BPD

TW: mentions of self harm and suicidal thoughts/actions

At the best of times, the symptoms of borderline personality disorder (BPD) are like listening to rain gently tapping on your bedroom window; you know it’s there and that it’s probably going to continue to rain for a while, but it’s not necessarily distressing and the noise can easily pass you by. 

At the worst of times, it feels like the rain has poured through a gap in your window and is filling up your room while you’re struggling to keep your head above the water. 

all Essays opinion

We Need Accessibility This Mental Health Awareness Week, not Pretty Speeches

Trigger warning: this article mentions suicidal thoughts and suicide, in particular the deaths by suicide of Robin Williams and Caroline Flack.

The moment I opened my Twitter feed on Monday morning, I was greeted by the hashtag I’d secretly been dreading: #MentalHealthAwarenessWeek.

This isn’t because I’m against raising awareness, quite the opposite, but I emphatically dislike the way in which lip service is paid to mental health rather than genuine support. Most of the people I see on my socials share the same disillusionment. We’re tired of being told to reach out when in need, that everyone understands, only to be met with indifference when we act on this.

all Essays opinion

How my Chinese heritage made me feel ashamed about being disabled

Disability and mental health; these two concepts stimulate a huge amount of taboo within the Chinese culture. Growing up, these were rarely discussed and on the rare occasion that my parents or other adults did mention them, it was always with a negative undertone and conveyed the message that these individuals were somehow weaker and less deserving.

all Essays opinion

Your Platitude Isn’t Helping my Mental Health

Trigger warnings: Suicide. Mental health disbelief. Mention of medication/addiction.

Talking about mental health is important. It’s the first step towards getting help. It helps reduce stigma. It can help you find people who can support your recovery.

But talking to the wrong people can be nothing short of disastrous. People who are dismissive. People who are laissez-faire in the extreme. People who – be they trained professionals, public figures, or strangers on the internet – give awful advice.

all News opinion

The changes to the Mental Health Act are great for autistic people, but it’s not enough

TW: This post mentions institutional abuse of disabled people.

Recently, it was announced that the Mental Health Act would be facing some landmark reforms in order to tackle its discriminatory overuse against some of the most vulnerable groups in society.